Loading...

| by Oliver El-Gorr |
6 Min Read

Should you sell cash-secured puts on a stock you wouldn’t want to own?

No. A cash-secured put is an agreement to buy 100 shares at the strike price if the option is assigned, so you should only sell one on a company you would be happy to own at that price. The test is the same for any stock that arrives in your account: what is it worth, and what am I paying?

What happens when you sell a cash-secured put

You collect a premium and set aside enough cash to buy 100 shares at the strike price. If the stock stays above the strike, the option expires and you keep the premium. If it falls below, you may be assigned and have to buy the shares.

Worked example (hypothetical numbers)

  • A stock trades at $52. You sell one 30-day put with a $50 strike for $1.20 a share, collecting $120.
  • You set aside $5,000 in cash to cover the purchase.
  • If assigned, your effective cost is $50 minus $1.20, or $48.80 a share.
  • If the stock then falls to $40, you hold shares worth $4,000 that effectively cost $4,880. That is an unrealised loss of $880.

Whether $48.80 was a price worth paying depends entirely on whether you wanted the company in the first place.

A real-world version of the same question

In October 2026, Elon Musk said committees of independent directors at Tesla and SpaceX were weighing a possible merger. Most analysts expected an all-stock deal. On the figures reported at the time, SpaceX was valued at about $2 trillion and Tesla at about $1.5 trillion, which would make SpaceX roughly 57% of a combined company before any premium and Tesla 43%.

A Tesla shareholder would then own a company that is mostly SpaceX. Oliver El-Gorr, who holds Tesla but not SpaceX, said he likes SpaceX as a business but cannot justify paying about $2 trillion for it. His point: if a swap put those shares in his account, he would face a question he had already answered: would I buy this at this price? Shares handed to you still need a reason to be owned.

Assignment on a put works the same way. The shares arrive whether or not you chose them in the moment, so the choice has to be made before you sell the option.

A simple checklist before selling a put

  • Would I buy 100 shares at this strike price today if I had the cash?
  • Do I understand what the business is worth, and is the strike a price I am comfortable paying?
  • Can I hold the shares through a fall without being forced to sell?
  • Do I have a plan if I am assigned, such as selling covered calls, which is the wheel strategy?

Frequently asked questions

What is a cash-secured put?

A put option you sell while holding enough cash to buy 100 shares at the strike price. You receive a premium for taking on the obligation to buy.

What happens if I get assigned?

You buy 100 shares at the strike price. Your effective cost is the strike minus the premium you collected.

Is selling puts the same as getting paid to wait for a lower price?

It can work that way, but the stock can fall well below the strike, in which case you can lose money. That is why the company has to be one you would be willing to own.

How does this connect to the wheel strategy?

The wheel starts with selling cash-secured puts. If you are assigned, you then sell covered calls on the shares you own. It only makes sense on stocks you want to hold.

About the author: Oliver El-Gorr is the founder of Freeman Publications and author of multiple best-selling options and investing books.

Call to action: Learn how to use cash-secured puts, covered calls and the wheel sensibly. Join the free Freeman Publications newsletter (https://emails.freemanpublications.com/subscribe?utm_source=website&utm_campaign=own-what-you-buy)

Educational content only, not financial advice or a recommendation of any security. Options involve risk and are not suitable for every investor. Examples use hypothetical numbers.

Customer satisfaction is our ultimate goal

What our readers say about us;

Ready to find the next Amazon, Tesla, or Netflix?

Join Our Free Investing Community

Join Now For Free